Thursday, August 7, 2008

Still on B or C

The 28th June 2008 police report reported by Rocky's Bru, and which we obtained from The People's Parliament which we reproduce here: 
“Saya Mohd Saiful Bukhari b Azlan ingin melaporkan bahawa saya telah diliwat oleh majikan saya. Perkara ini berlaku tanpa kerelaan saya. Kejadian terakhir berlaku 26/6/08 di Unit 1151, Kondominium Desa Damansara, Jln Setia Kasih, KL. Oleh itu, tujuan laporan ini dibuat untuk mendapat pembelaan dan keadilan keatas diri saya. Saya juga berasa bimbang dengan keselamatan diri dan keluarga saya jika perkara ini tersebar luas di khalayak ramai. Majikan saya Dato Seri Anwar Ibrahim - Ketua Umum PKR.”

We think that "tanpa kerelaan" means without consent, or involuntarily.  So it cant be S.377B since that requires voluntary conduct.  It also cant be S.377C even though that covers "tanpa kerelaan" as the Pusrawi medical report has ruled out assault.  In fact, this also means that both S.377B and S.377C are ruled out by the fact that the Pusrawi medical report has ruled out sodomy altogether, with or without consent!

But it seems that within MCA, what we the grassroots think is not important.  What is important within MCA is what the MCA President and the MCA Sec-Gen thinks.  So: what do you think, Mr MCA President and Mr MCA Sec-Gen?  Or for that matter, what does anybody from the MCA top leadership think?
mca74justice

No comments: